Search This Blog

Monday, November 16, 2026

I Made Yogurt

Inspired by the linked video, I decided to try to make yogurt. 

I used a modified version of her "incubate it in the oven" method. Rather than transferring the yogurt-to-be from the sauce-pan to a jar, I just put the sauce-pan in the oven.  The oven light kept the temperature in the oven only to 84, rather than close to the 110 she recommends.  Part of the reason for that might be that I'm currently keeping the house at only 65.

So, since the incubation temperature was so low, the result the next morning was far from ideal.  It was edible, and it tasted fine, but it was really runny.  It ran right through the cheesecloth, even after chilling it in the refrigerator.

Later in the day, I decided to see whether I could re-start the incubation process.  So, I turned on the oven for a few minutes to warm it up.  Of course, the temperature in the oven was now far too high, But, I was hoping that between the mass of the sauce-pan and the mass of the chilled not-quite yogurt, the cultures would survive until the oven temperature dropped.  And it worked out. At this moment, most of the whey has drained from the yogurt, and the yogurt has a nice "Greek style" consistency.

Whether I do this on-going, I'm going to make at least the gallon of milk (*) I bought into yogurt.  So, from that gallon of milk, I'll get nearly four quarts of yogurt for less cost than the single quarts of yogurt I have been buying.  Even a quart of yogurt made from half-and-half will cost less than the bought yogurt.

(*) I'm not much a milk drinker: I've had even single quarts go bad before I use them.  A couple of years ago, I started buying quarts of half-and-half, rather than regular milk.  I really like the taste of half-and-half, and so far I managed to not have any go bad.

EDIT: Well, no. I'll probably get only about two quarts of finished yogurt from the gallon of milk, once the whew can be separated. With regular milk, that's still cheaper than the bought yogurt. Yogurt made from half-and-half will be more expensive, but I'm going to do it at least once to see what it's like.

Becoming a Farm Girl: I Don’t Buy Greek Yogurt Anymore — 2 Ingredients, 3 Ways (No Tools)

0 comments: